QI Watchdown: H15 (Hypnosis, Hallucinations and Hysteria) or ‘NOT THERE. MIRAAAAAGE.’

A few future trends that started with this episode- titling an episode with three long concepts instead of just a single word, stacking Phill Jupitus as the only semi-regular on a panel of two occasionals, and having Ronni Ancona on the panel only to shortcharge her in the edit. Tonight’s episode also has a…special-ish guest- Robert Webb is here, in his only appearance.

Stephen talks about a disease that causes hydrosceles of the scrotum.
Alan: “makes your scrotum go into a triangle?”
Stephen: “…no that would be ISOSCELES…this is Hydrosceles…”
Phill: “AND HE NEVER ATE DAIRY AGAIN…”

Stephen continues, that this man’s scrotum grew to 40 kilos, and he ended up using it as a writing desk, which gets a response from the audience.
Ronni: “That’s a good attitude to have!”
Phill: “Yeah, I’d get a sharpie and paint the face on the front of a spacehopper onto mine…”
Alan: “I’d make mine look like a hedgehog..”

Stephen says that this Scottish doctor used hypnosis to a success with this patient.
Phill: “Your eyyyes arre heavy. “NOT AS HEAVY AS ME TESTICLES!”

Stephen says that pain comes from the brain, and is basically information.
Rob: “I can imagine someone banging on my thumb, and going “IT’S JUST INFORMATION! IT’S JUST INFORMATION!”

Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.04.03 PM.pngStephen: “There is a very small hammerhead shark…”
Alan: “That is a toy shark.”
Phill: “Or a REALLY big diver?”
Stephen: “a frighteningly big diver…”
Phill: “I think we’d have heard of HIM…”

Stephen says that chickens can be hypnotized by holding a stick with fake eyeballs on them to them, and they’ll stare.
Ronni: “You just made that up!”
Stephen: “It’s in all the books, all the-”
Rob: “What, in all the books?  All the chicken-hypnotizing books?”
Phill: “Which is why you must NEVER let your chickens watch The Muppets.”
Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.08.20 PM.png

Stephen: “D’you know how you wake them up, rabbits and guinea pigs, if they’re in that state?”
Alan: “…you let the dog in.”

Stephen talks about how he hypnotized a lobster in Maine, and attempts it in the studio, saying “it won’t move a muscle.”
Phill cracks up. Stephen realizes the pun: “Oh, MUSSEL!”

Then Stephen brings up a dog that could hypnotize humans, “Oscar the Hypno-Dog.”

Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.12.41 PM.png

Just looking at the dog cracks me (and Phill) up

Alan: “I’m feeling it now…I’ll go and get the biscuits.”
Stephen: “The thing is…he could keep up that stare with a human for hours on end-”
[Jupitus giggling]
Rob: “Depending on what human would WANT to be stared at for that long…”

Stephen says that life flashing before your eyes is a way of your brain trying to find a past memory that will help you survive.
Ronni: “It’s pretty risky, though, isn’t it? You’re on the brink of death, and you’re rerunning, and you’re going “NO, NOT MY FATHER’S 70TH BIRTHDAY!”
Stephen: “Or…if you lose your keys, just put your head facedown in the basin, and start drowning yourself, until you get to the point where you last had them.”

Ronni brings up a great point: “D’you think that…with rising crime, that death’s door has become more security conscious?”
She’s actually good in small doses, and has good comedic points, but sometimes she’ll flag for the spotlight, or something Stephen will cut her off before she gets going.

Stephen reveals that there’s a cat with a degree in psychotherapy.
Phill: “I think Oscar’s sitting opposite her!”

Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.29.27 PM.png

(Phill does a quick Oscar impression)

Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.31.44 PM.pngAlan: “Are those hats falling from the sky? Oh, there are hands beneath them.”
Stephen: “Yes, there are.”
Alan: “Is that how you get your hat? They’re dropped out of a plane, and you have to catch them?”
Phill: “I’d like to think that underneath that photo, there are about 60 cats…”

The next question involves Stephen being elected Pope, and…
Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.41.11 PM.png

Screen Shot 2017-01-26 at 11.41.25 PM.png

(Phill’s reaction is mine)

Stephen mentions that the Subliminal Messaging thing was even used in the Young Ones.
Rob: “Goes back to my childhood…”
Ronni: “Your childhood???”
Rob: “Yes, Ronni. Deal with it.”

Phill actually talks about a Judas Priest song that, in backmasking, allegedly encouraged people to commit suicide.
Stephen: “Halford even said ‘I don’t wish to paint myself as greedy, but if we were gonna put a message in, it would have been ‘buy more of our records…’ I mean, he also said ‘DO IT’ doesn’t mean ‘kill yourself.”
Phill, chuckling: “Stephen, the song WAS called ‘suicide solution’…”
(As Youtube Commenters have revealed…it wasn’t, but still)
Phill, crossing over to Buzzcocks: “FINALLY, BEING IN A POP QUIZ PAYS OFF!”

Stephen, summing up the round: “So, subliminal advertising DOESN’T Stephenfryforpope WORK…”

Stephen: “In the Catholic church, it is a sin to be superstitious…”
Ronni: “You’ll change that when you’re pope, won’t you?”
Phill: “AND AS POPE STEPHEN WALKS OUT ONTO THE BALCONY…UNDERNEATH A LADDER…WITH SEVERAL BLACK CATS…”

On the sight question:
Stephen: “So, what about Hitler?”
Phill: “What ABOUT Hitler?”
Rob: “LEAVE HITLER ALONE! WEEK AFTER WEEK!”

And now, the most famous part of this episode:
Stephen asks the panel to pinpoint the exact point where the sun goes below the horizon. Everyone buzzes way too late.
Screen Shot 2017-01-27 at 12.01.51 AM.png
Screen Shot 2017-01-27 at 12.02.01 AM.png

Stephen explains that after a certain point it’s just a mirage, and it’s much earlier…which infuriates the panel, including Phill.

Phill: “IIIIII….HATE THIS SHOW. BECAUSE…the sun…IS THERE. And you’re going [Stephen impression] “NOOO.” “It’s the SUN!” “NOT THERE…..MIRAAAAAAGGGGE.”

Alan explains that in New Zealand, the hot sun bouncing off the road in low-elevation can cause blindness.”
Phill: “I dare say that the drivers in New Zealand, as they see the sun setting, are REASSURED TO KNOWWW….THAT IT’S *NOT THERE*.”

Screen Shot 2017-01-27 at 12.07.41 AM.pngPhill just holds this expression as Stephen sums up the round. He’s absolutely heartbroken.

First Question of GI:
Stephen: “What shape is this staircase?”
Phill: “IT’S *NOT THEEEERE!*”
Stephen: “NOW PHILL…”

Rob buzzes in just to guess ‘spiral’, and waves his hands in the air as the klaxon sounds. It’s almost like a Jo Brand reaction.

Stephen talks about ducks and their spiral genitalia.
Alan: “When they procreate, does it kinda spin in like a screw?”
Phill: “And, if push comes to shove, and you’re in Argentina with a bottle of Merlot…”

Stephen: “Not only that, but it has the longest penis, relative to its body size, of any vertebrae.”
Phill: “Do you know that, or did the duck tell you?”

Stephen goes further, that the duck has a brush on the end.
Phill: “WOW, You can clean up after!”
Alan: “Like a Dyson!”

Stephen: “What do you think the brush is for?”
Phill, giddy: “GETTIN’ BEHIND THE CURTAINS!”

Rob gets another Klaxon by guessing the Molotov fellow created the Molotov cocktail…and again, he’s ecstatic about. Rob didn’t do a ton in this episode, but his enthusiasm, and his ability to collaborate, was pretty damn amusing.
Alan: “He invented the…slow, comfortable screw against the wall?”

Rob actually gets last this episode, which is…odd, but unsurprising.

Even as Stephen announces that Phill has won (with -2), he’s still pissed about the sun. He’s shaking his head, going “I’m not happy…I’m not happy…”

Overall: Not as good as last week, but still a pretty enjoyable show, especially for a series with a ton of middle of the road episodes. Phill gave this one a major boost, with some Grade A stuff from him, the likes of which we’ve not seen in a little while, but Rob had a few nice moments, and while Ronni was shortchanged by Stephen and the edit, she did have some good lines here and there. Also, Alan was in a great mood, because he and Phill work insanely well together. Some great moments, definitely rewatchable.

MVP: Phill
Best Guest: Phill
Show Winner: Phill
Best QI Fact: Oscar the Hypno-Dog
Best Runner: IT’S NOT THERE.

Nevermind Watchdown: S24E11, or I’ll Never Be Allowed Back in a Zoo…

Onto another episode, this one the second-to-last episode of Series 24, which is kind of huge. This season’s been kind of rocky, and there have been high points, as well as incredibly low points (thanks Westwood), but the last two shows look very optimistic. This one hosted by Robert Webb, who’ll probably give a pretty nice performance, and featuring Mock the Week recurring guest Andi Osho, rapper Example, TV Nature presenter Chris Packham, and…wait, shit, CEE-LO GREEN IS HERE?

Even for 2010, Cee-Lo would have been a pretty big get, as his big hit ‘Fuck You’ was just hitting the charts, and he’d already been coasting on Gnarls Barkley money for 5 years. So, while I’m super glad he’s here, it’s a marvel that he agreed to come on.

Robert’s already showing he’s a great pick to host with his first intro-clip standup, on Lady Gaga: “She likes the feeling of animal flesh against her skin- PUT YOUR COCK AWAY, PACKHAM, IT WAS ONLY A DRESS!”

Screen Shot 2016-12-02 at 9.58.36 PM.png

Noel: “I love the fact that someone answers a baguette.”
Rob: “If you leave it, it’ll just get stale, so you’ve got to pick it up, keep it fresh…”
Phill: “Now that Noel has actually said that, within a month, Apple will bring out the iLoaf.”
Rob: “…good. Good iPun work there.”
Phill: “Apparently you get signal droppage if you put cheese and pickle in it.”

Rob gives a big buildup to Chris, saying he’s been around the world with animals: “What, in your opinion, is, in fact, the most interesting animal you’ve ever slept with?”
Chris: “It’s difficult…as there’s quite a few to choose from.”
[Phill completely loses it, across the studio]

Chris talks about a time where he ‘metaphorically’ slept with a tapir, but everybody’s screwing with him.
Noel: “Was it full penetration?”
Chris: “Well, it wasn’t penetrative, but it did climax…”
Phill: “What do you tell the guy at the dry-cleaning that is?”
Rob: “That’s the usual, uh, tapir *COUGH* uh, stain…”

Chris: “It was a tame tapir, that had been hand-reared.”
[Jupitus giggling]
Rob: “Very lovingly…”
Chris: “I didn’t hand-rear it, obviously…”
Andi: “Because, otherwise, it’d just be revenge…”

Chris: “I think that one of the great privileges of my job is that I get to be very tactile with animals.”
The whole room completely loses it.
Screen Shot 2016-12-06 at 12.20.24 AM.png
Chris: “Uh, legally…”

After the animal genitalia conversation
Robert: “Cee-Lo, are you regretting your decision to come here tonight? Were you under the impression that this was some kind of QUIZ?”

Rob tries rearing it back towards the question:
Noel: “All I can think of now is you getting…rodgered by a tapir, now. And Michaela Strachan- I used to fancy her when I was at school…”
Example: “I did too, she was quite a fit…for a bit…”
Rob: “WELL, WHO’S A CHARMER?”

Phill and Andi have a nice bit about putting more goofy sound effects in porn. Noel, STILL OBSESSED, suggests putting a tapir in the shot. HE’S STUCK.

Phill, pondering the Jonas Brothers’ purity ring kerfuffle: ‘Do they think that every time somebody has sex before marriage, a kitten dies?”
Robert: “I hope that’s not true…”
Noel: “Chris is NOT HAPPY about that…”

Noel, to Cee-Lo: “I read somewhere that you learned to sing using things around the house.”
Cee-Lo: “Yeah, imitating other artists that I liked.”
Noel: “Oh, I thought you meant, like, the kettle, and the toaster…that’s not as interesting of a fact…”

Noel and Cee-Lo’s first Intro is just amazing, aside from the fact that…Cee-Lo Green is here, doing intros, but it evokes a miracle in Chris:
Chris: “You know, I’ve been watching these for years, and I never get this bit…but that was Close to Me, by the Cure.”

As the actual clip plays, Noel: “Ay, Robert Smith got me laid when I was younger….not perso-he didn’t come ’round my house…”
(It’s a shame, because one of Noel’s predecessors was Robert Smith’s son, apparently..)

Chris: “Noel’s sounded a bit Dusty Springfield”
Noel: “Uh, to be honest, I’d focus on him..”

Rob, after a Sinatra ability: “Despite his limited musical ability, he furthered his career by getting into bed with one of the most brutal, ruthless godfathers in the…hang on, that’s not Sinatra, is it? That’s Sinitta.”
The audience even gives him some applause for that one.

Chris, on the ID Parade: “I remember Pauline being very petite, very short…”
Noel: “You sure that wasn’t a red squirrel?”

Phill, to Chris: “You did a thing on Springwatch where you were dropping song titles when you talked about animals. Am I imagining that?”
Chris: “No, I dropped a Smiths song title, and then the Cure, and then the Jesus and Mary Chain. The triumph was ‘Killing an Arab’…”
[Jupitus giggling]
Phill: “How did you manage that, then?”
Chris: “Well, I got Kate to end a sentence with the word ‘Killing’, and I began the next sentence with ‘An Arab Stallion’.”
THE WHOLE ROOM APPLAUDS THIS. Chris may be a bit neurotic, but he’s a wonderful presence on the show, and he gets the fact that the joke’s not always on him, but the joke is welcome.

Rob’s names for ‘Teenage Warning’ are pretty great:
“#2, Teenage Dirtbag:
Screen Shot 2016-12-06 at 1.03.51 AM.png
#3, Teenagers Beware:

Screen Shot 2016-12-06 at 1.04.35 AM.png

He looks like ‘THREE BILLY GOATS GRUFF’ guy from the Mark years!

#4, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle.

Screen Shot 2016-12-06 at 1.05.48 AM.png

(He was already gone before the camera even got to him..)

Screen Shot 2016-12-06 at 1.06.48 AM.png
Example: “Maybe he’s grown up, and he doesn’t want anymore of that teenager stuff, so he’s like ‘I’ll be a taxi driver now.”
Rob: “I can’t say I’d happily get into the taxi…driven by ANY of these men…”

Andi: “3’s giving me Eagles…I can’t say-”
Example: “3 looks like Santa in the summer!”

Next Lines:
Rob: “Lady, take me high upon a hillside”
Example, channeling Bill Bailey: “and…do me, proper.”

Rob: “You don’t have to be rich to be my girl.”
Example, now channeling Sean Hughes: “…but it would help..”

After two straight Packham-related lines (both ‘The Bad Touch’ and ‘Tie me kangaroo down, sport’ get a ‘by Chris Packham’)
Rob: “Waiting ’round the bend.”
Andi: “IT’S CHRIS PACKHAM! No?”
Chris: “…I’ll never be allowed back in a zoo…”

Plus, with Noel’s team, any animal-related song gets credited to Chris Packham, like ‘Wild Horses’.
Rob: “Love Cats…”
Chris: “…never touch them.”
Rob: “You’re right, Chris, that’s illegal…”

Overall: A pretty evenly-placed and all-around fun show. Robert Webb was probably the standard of guest hosts this season- he didn’t go above and beyond like Josh Groban and Terry Wogan, but he ran the show expediently and gave a lot of really nice jokes. Cee-Lo was a slight disappointment, but just Cee-Lo being there was enough for me, really. Chris Packham had the best night of anybody, because he got a lot of people poking fun at him, and he responded not by crumbling but by taking it all in and basking in it. Andi and Example had some really nice lines, but the focus was more on Noel’s side, really.

Guest Host Rating: 9.5/10. A pretty excellent job for Robert.
Best Regular: Noel
Best Guest: Chris
Best Runner: Chris Packham buggering animals.

Nevermind Watchdown: S22E10, or Out to the Sheds, Simon..

Two more episodes left of the Simon Amstell era. Two big ones.

A few notable guests here. The Guest Bill is Dermot O’Leary, TV presenter and…guy who hasn’t been on since 2000. Arlene Phillips is also here, as is Rob Webb, David Mitchell’s sparring partner. But…more importantly…Dappy, from N-Dubz, has somehow returned to Buzzcocks…and I have no idea how Simon’s gonna deal with this.

Also, Keith Murray from We Are Scientists is also here. So yeah.

The runner for this episode is that, in an effort to clean up the profanities, Simon brings out an adorable kitten and says that with every curse word, he will suffer with his life.

Phill on Cliff Richard, to Arlene: “Did he do what you said?”
Arlene: “I tried…to get him to do what I wanted.”
Phill: “Of course, as a woman, that would be tricky…”

Keith says he’s never heard of Cliff.
Simon: “Now that you have, do you wish that you got Cliff and we got Elvis?”
Phill: “Well, I wish *CLIFF* was dead…”

Arlene, still on Cliff: “I think there are many people in the world, who would like to know his secret…”
Phill: “Well, I think most of us do.”

Arlene: “If I could, I’d tell the doctors to start and my ankles and not stop.”
Simon: “You’re right, your ankles do look shit.”
He then realizes what he’s done, and looks at the cat down below the desk.
Dermot: “I think you should start with one of his paws.”
He does, and you hear an offscreen frightened mew.

Simon asks if there’s a rivalry between Dermot and Arlene.
Dermot: “We’ve seen each other around, but…when you’re a jet, you’re a jet and all…”
Keith: “…I ACTUALLY UNDERSTOOD THAT!”

After Simon reads from Dappy’s bio
Dappy: “You know, some of the things you say come off as very sarcastic.”
Dermot: “He has elements of sarcasm about him, but I believe when he congratulated you about the MoBo and the Gold Disk”
Simon: “No, I really mean it.”
Dappy: “Thank you, Simon.”
Simon: “See, one day I’ll get really good at this sincerity thing, and they’ll hand me the big money…”

Simon, to Dermot: “I’m reluctant even to bring this up, but what happened to poor Kate Thornton?”
There’s an audible ‘Oooh’ from the audience.
Simon: “Some people are shocked I’ve brought this up, some people have already forgotten she’s existed.”

Dermot: “It’s like when you ask someone…who’s daughter you’re gonna marry. Like, you know you’re gonna marry them but you sort of want to get permission, so I called her up and she was very gracious, and lovely about it.”
Rob: “Is that why Russell Brand was ringing Andrew Sachs?”
SAVAGE. And this was right in the thick of the controversy, too.

Simon: “Everyone has their pre-gig rituals. Interestingly enough, every since Dermot took over presenting the X-Factor, before each show starts, Kate Thornton downs a half-bottle of gin, and a fistful of painkillers.”
Screen Shot 2016-10-07 at 12.03.07 AM.png
Simon: “JUST A JOKE! It’s you every week dancing on HER grave!”
Screen Shot 2016-10-07 at 12.04.01 AM.png

Arlene, after having no idea about Phill’s 2nd intro: “Before I went on, my daughter said to me “you shouldn’t do this, because you’re not gonna get one of ’em right.” And that’s true, because-”
Keith: “But you lived up to your daughter’s expectations, which is pretty nice…”

Earlier in the episode, Simon even gave Arlene a paddle to spank Simon with. After a joke about Cheryl Cole (“isn’t it funny that we’ve all forgotten what a horrible thug she is?”), Dermot goes over, and threatens to take Simon “out to the sheds”…only to break the paddle entirely.

Phill’s ID Parade involves guessing the drummer from Slade. Phill has been seen with Dave Hill AND Noddy Holder. Phill is going to win.

Simon’s name for #3 of ‘Pass the Dutchie’ is “Pass the gin, O’Leary’s on again…”
Screen Shot 2016-10-07 at 12.16.39 AM.png

Simon goes back to Dermot about X Factor
Simon: “My favorite bit about the final…is that you get all those auditionees-”
Dermot: ‘AW, YEAH THAT’S THE BEST BIT!”
Simon: “Like, the most mentally ill ones. What, do you call up their respective institutions?”
Phill: “For the especially mad ones, Louis goes out in a LandRover with a dart gun. It’s like Jurassic Park.”

The Musical Youth ID Parade comes to a standstill. Rob and Dermot like #1, especially his ‘calming eyes’, but Dappy’s convinced it’s #3, even saying “if you guys guess one and it’s 3, I’m walking off.”
Sure enough, 3 steps forward, and Dappy jokes like he’s going to pull a Preston…but in reality he just goes over and hi-five/bro-hugs the Musical Youth member. As crazy as he is, Dappy’s been pretty cool this episode, kind of dialed back.

Next Lines: “I don’t wanna be pushy-pushy.”
Dermot, completely straight-faced: “I…would just like some pussy-pussy.”
Simon: “Correct. N-Dubz.”
Dappy: “YEEESSSS!!!”
He fives the hell out of Dermot. This is fantastic.

Overall: Not perfect, but a fun show with some nice moments. Obviously the dynamic between the dueling variety show personalities, Dermot and Arlene, was great. Arlene was having a ball, and Dermot was a great guest host, especially in putting up with Simon. Though he wasn’t the greatest connector, except in small cases with Rob, and Dappy just ambushing him. Keith and Rob had nice moments, if smaller. Dappy was surprisingly more composed this time, and had a lot less material for Simon to work with. Fine show, even if the middle was a bit dry.

Guest Host Rating: 8.5/10. If it means anything, Dermot, you showed a ton more personality than Ryan Seacrest.
Best Regular: Phill
Best Guest: Arlene
Best Runner: Simon shooting the kitten.